• Home  
  • Climate Distress Took Two Consumer Paths in a 582-Person Turkish Study
- Society

Climate Distress Took Two Consumer Paths in a 582-Person Turkish Study

A Turkish mixed-methods study found climate anxiety and eco-grief followed different moral routes linked to impulsive buying and environmentally conscious behaviour.

Reusable shopping bags and consumer products beside a window overlooking a dry landscape

Climate distress does not point in one direction

Anxiety about climate change can motivate a person to act more responsibly.

It may also coincide with impulse purchases made for temporary emotional relief.

That apparent contradiction is the focus of a new study of adults in Türkiye.

Instead of treating climate distress as either helpful or harmful, the researchers examined whether different forms of moral reasoning connect climate emotions to distinct consumer responses.

Their evidence suggests two routes can coexist: one through a stronger sense of responsibility and another through justifications that make questionable purchases easier to accept.

The findings are associations from survey data, supported by interviews, not proof that a particular feeling causes a person to buy something or behave sustainably.

The people behind the evidence

Özgür Çengel, Munise Hayrun Sağlam and Elif Türk used an explanatory sequential mixed-methods design.

First came a cross-sectional online survey of 582 adult consumers living in Türkiye who had made at least one discretionary purchase in the preceding month.

Invitations were distributed in September 2025.

Of 1,450 people invited, 596 completed the questionnaire and 582 responses remained after predetermined screening checks, giving a usable response rate of 40.1%.

Approximately a month later, researchers interviewed 26 people about their feelings, justifications and consumption choices.

This design provided quantitative patterns and explanatory accounts, but the qualitative interviews did not independently prove that the modelled processes occurred in the order proposed.

Anxiety, grief and place-based distress differ

The study distinguished climate-change anxiety from ecological grief.

Anxiety concerns threats and potential future harm, while eco-grief involves emotional responses to ecological loss.

A further concept, solastalgia, describes distress associated with deterioration of a familiar or valued place.

The researchers investigated whether this localised sense of loss changes the way climate emotions relate to moral reasoning.

These concepts overlap in everyday experience but should not be collapsed into a single negative-emotion score.

Someone can feel grief about a disappearing river and anxiety about future heatwaves while still responding differently to each concern.

In the study, all three were measured through participants’ reported experiences rather than verified environmental exposure records.

Two different moral processes

Moral obligation is the sense that environmental responsibility should influence personal behaviour.

Moral disengagement refers to ways people justify actions that might conflict with their own standards, such as minimising the impact of one purchase or comparing it favourably with the pollution of a much larger organisation.

The study related these moral processes to two outcome constructs: eco-conscious behaviour and affective impulsive buying.

The latter includes urges, excitement and difficulty resisting attractive purchases, not only luxury spending or products shown to be environmentally harmful.

That limitation is important.

A higher impulse-buying score cannot be translated into a measured carbon footprint, and self-reported environmentally conscious behaviour is not the same as objectively verified emissions reduction.

What the quantitative study found

Using partial least squares structural equation modelling, the researchers reported that climate-change anxiety was positively associated with both moral disengagement and moral obligation.

Eco-grief, by contrast, was positively associated with moral obligation and negatively associated with moral disengagement.

Moral disengagement was associated with greater affective impulsive buying, while moral obligation was associated with stronger eco-conscious behaviour.

The corresponding indirect associations were statistically significant within the model.

That pattern is compatible with multiple emotional routes rather than one inevitable reaction.

Yet the variables were measured in the same survey, so those indirect estimates do not demonstrate that emotion came first, caused a change in moral reasoning and then altered real purchases.

Where solastalgia entered the model

The study tested whether solastalgia moderated the links from climate emotions to moral responses.

Higher place-based distress strengthened the positive association between climate-change anxiety and moral disengagement, with a reported interaction coefficient of 0.108.

It weakened the positive association between eco-grief and moral obligation, with an interaction coefficient of −0.138.

Both were reported as statistically significant, but the authors described the interaction effect sizes as small.

Solastalgia was therefore not a dominant switch that automatically turns grief into resignation or anxiety into shopping.

It was an associated contextual condition that slightly changed the strength of selected relationships in this Turkish sample.

Why impulse buying cannot be called climate harm here

The survey included a ten-item measure of affective impulsive buying that assessed emotional urges and purchasing reactions.

It did not restrict the outcome to high-carbon goods, disposable fashion or any other product category with demonstrated environmental consequences.

Thus the data support a link between moral disengagement and a tendency toward emotionally driven purchases, not a calculation of additional emissions.

Similarly, the study did not track bank-card transactions, shopping baskets or longitudinal purchasing behaviour.

A person can report guilt after a purchase or stronger impulse tendencies without acting on those tendencies in every situation.

Studies that connect consent-based shopping records to measured environmental impacts would be needed to turn the present psychological associations into claims about actual ecological outcomes.

How the interviews gave those paths human texture

The researchers conducted semi-structured interviews in October 2025 with 26 purposively selected participants to explore reasoning that might help explain the survey patterns.

They identified six themes rather than pretending every story followed the same path.

Some people described visible changes to familiar landscapes followed by rationalisations about their limited responsibility.

Others connected ecological loss with practical commitments such as repairing possessions, reducing travel or supporting local initiatives.

A theme concerning perceived urgency captured the desire to enjoy certain experiences before environmental change made them less accessible.

These interviews make the model’s ideas more understandable, but their purpose was analytic explanation rather than statistical representation of all consumers in Türkiye.

Digital badges and delegated responsibility

One interview theme concerned people treating environmental badges, product filters and platform claims as a kind of moral authorisation.

When an app labels an item as a lower-carbon choice, the consumer may treat that signal as sufficient reason not to examine the quantity or need for the purchase.

The researchers described this as algorithmic absolution: responsibility is shifted to an interface or external certification.

Their interviews reported this reasoning, but the study did not independently test whether the badges were accurate or whether changing the interface would cause purchases to rise or fall.

The practical question for retailers is therefore testable rather than settled: can claims be presented clearly enough to inform decisions without implying that every associated purchase is environmentally harmless?

Repair, reuse and local action offered another response

Other participants spoke about repairing shoes, buying second-hand items, exchanging goods or taking part in local environmental initiatives.

Such activities were described as ways to restore a sense of agency when broader climate threats felt overwhelming.

Some interviewees mixed seemingly contradictory responses, such as making an indulgent purchase and later choosing an environmentally oriented activity.

That complexity matters for interpreting moral behaviour.

People are not permanently assigned to one psychological pathway.

Their decisions may vary with resources, opportunity, emotions and the information available at a particular moment.

The interviews did not test whether those actions objectively offset previous environmental impacts; they documented how respondents understood and justified their choices.

Local landscape loss can coexist with stewardship

Participants also described threats to familiar places and the desire to support those places through local buying or community programmes.

The existence of such responses qualifies any simple claim that solastalgia must suppress environmental responsibility.

In the survey model, place-based distress weakened one positive statistical link; in the interview narratives, people sometimes retained a strong sense of stewardship despite that distress.

These observations can coexist because the model estimates average associations while interview accounts expose individual variation.

Future research could test perceived agency directly, rather than inferring it from conversations, to examine whether practical opportunities for action explain why people respond differently to similar environmental emotions.

A snapshot cannot establish a behavioural sequence

All survey constructs were recorded at one point in time.

Participants who already favour environmentally conscious shopping may report a greater moral obligation, and those who frequently buy impulsively may rationalise their behaviour after the fact.

Socioeconomic circumstances and trust in institutions could influence both.

The model’s mediation paths should therefore be described as statistical indirect associations, not proven causal mechanisms.

The subsequent interviews occurred about a month later, but they drew on retrospective reports rather than observing a continuous sequence of emotions, thoughts and purchases.

The investigators explicitly called for longitudinal and experimental work to establish what changes first and what interventions might alter subsequent behaviour.

The limitations of one national context

The sample was limited to consumers in Türkiye, and the interviews recruited volunteers with climate concerns and frequent online purchasing.

Cultural expectations, environmental exposures, retail systems and economic pressures can vary substantially across countries.

A survey that includes respondents who have already made discretionary purchases also excludes some people for whom financial constraints sharply limit that choice.

Measures of eco-grief and solastalgia drew on participants’ perceptions, not direct attribution of local changes to global climate processes.

These boundaries matter before applying the results to other markets or making claims about those suffering the greatest environmental harm.

Replication should test whether the scales carry comparable meanings across languages and populations.

Related evidence and why comparisons matter

Research Today has explored adjacent questions in research on climate worry and food-related concern and an experiment testing crisis language about nature loss.

Those studies use different populations, measures and designs.

They do not confirm the moral-disengagement pathways estimated in this paper.

Comparing them helps reveal why research on environmental messages can produce seemingly conflicting headlines: concern, reported consumption intentions, moral justifications and observed behaviour are not interchangeable outcomes.

A controlled test of an environmental message can identify one kind of effect that a broad survey cannot, while a survey can identify psychological patterns that suggest what an experiment should investigate next.

What organisations can legitimately test

The authors suggest testing communications that strengthen agency and specify achievable environmental actions.

Retailers could examine whether clearer claims about the scope of an environmental label reduce mistaken impressions, while community groups could assess whether locally visible repair or restoration opportunities support participation.

Those are research proposals, not proven treatments.

Evaluations should measure actual behaviour, unintended consequences and potential pressure on individuals already experiencing climate distress.

Ethical communication should avoid exploiting anxiety, treating grief as a marketing opportunity or suggesting that a single purchase cancels out larger environmental problems.

Interventions need independent experimental evidence before their effects can be stated confidently.

The more nuanced conclusion

The research offers a useful way to understand why concern about climate change does not always translate into the same consumer response.

Among 582 surveyed adults in Türkiye, climate-change anxiety related positively to both moral disengagement and obligation, while ecological grief related positively to obligation and negatively to disengagement.

These processes were associated with different self-reported buying patterns, and solastalgia modestly altered two of the associations.

Interviews with 26 people added examples of rationalisation, immediate reward seeking, repair and stewardship.

The defensible takeaway is not that anxiety causes impulsive shopping or that grief guarantees sustainability.

It is that the emotional and moral context deserves much closer, causally informative study.

Source Information

Study title: Climate distress at a moral crossroads: how solastalgia conditions divergent consumer responses

Authors: Özgür Çengel, Munise Hayrun Sağlam, Elif Türk

Journal: Frontiers in Psychology

Publication date: 10 November 2026

Study design: Explanatory sequential mixed-methods research combining cross-sectional PLS-SEM survey modelling with later semi-structured interviews

Sample or scope: 582 adult consumers in Türkiye surveyed in September 2025 and 26 purposively selected interview participants in October 2025

Key finding: Climate-change anxiety related positively to moral disengagement and moral obligation, while eco-grief showed different patterns; solastalgia modestly moderated selected pathways

DOI: 10.3389/fpsyg.2026.1973974

Contact Us

Research Today is a South African digital publication that makes credible research easier to understand.

TERMS OF USE & PRIVACY POLICY

follow us